hello dear brother
hello sir ji
how are you
you have gone Arabic?
the script is the same?
yeah less difference
Is the language derived from Avestan language?
Persian is a branch of Indo-European language
but Arabic is Semic
I am traveling around these days
where are now?
I returned yesterday from Baroda
now i am in Delhi
You wrote an interesting point on three types of Islam
its from my article recently i published in kabul
what was your argument?
the ways how to amalgmate all these three
how will you do that?
to finish social inconsistencis within islamic society
but how to achieve it?
many ways are there
to establish DARUL TAQRIB MAZAHIB
i dont know how to translate
you can elaborate
once during Abbasid caliphate we had a discussion home of all different sects in islam
so during that period we did not have problem in society
I also belive that intellectual or literal unity is an opium
we should never be united or we should never believe in same thing in minor things
but in socia; practices or in society we should be united
kind of Islamic pluralism
it is kind of Dialectic
yes with tolerance
Do you know Ziauddin Sardar?
who is he
He is a British citizen
of Pakistani origin
I read his book
Journey of a sceptical Muslim
He is dissatisfied with almost all brands of Islam
but he is devoted to Prophet and the Holy Book
for islam that is important only
The book was his autobiography
branches and sects are not principle
It gave a pictureof all divergent thinkings within Islam
What about Muslim interactions with non-Muslims?
like in Indian civilization
like we in India are trying to build an Indian civilization
How can Islam participate in the process?
Islam can not participate in that
because there are these attempts like Indian, Persian, Tukish and all other civilization
kind of nationalism
but islam rejects nationalism at all
may be some muslim joins individually as political process
but religiously islam as religion does not support
and Muslim see india as a thread to islam
then what is the world-view of Islam towards other religions?
should they all cease to exist?
merge into Islam?
yes they can be exist
it is better if they merge to islam but as far as they dont so we live in peace and respect
Till they dont disturb us we live in peace with them, but from the time they stop us for preaching then JIHAD
will it involve bloodshed?
second jihad or small jihad is bloodshed
But does islam allow any flexibility to philosophical discourse?
Islam has its own philosophy
like can there be any space for Vedanta
or Yoga system?
Al Farabi is only one philosopher
Is there debate?
But one thing is there i told u before too
But the debate always has to be subordinate to Quran and Prophet
Last prophecy of Muhammad
life after death
all debatea are other than these three
what about karma theory?
transmigration of the soul
but he was killed
Al Musa Al Khawarzmi also debated this
some people they debated
But can they be debated again in new light?
1- Islamic philosophy is died after golden era finished
2- Almost all sects accepted some general belives
what is Irtidad?
I think Apososy
To reject someone from islam
but the believes can change
like Salman rushdie
not principle belive
if they are within Quran and Prophet teachings?
Like this fasting
if any muslim rejects then he is not muslim
5 pillars of Islam
he can do this not to keep fast
but he cant say it is not in islam
one group of American Black new converted
were fasting in december for one month
then first of january was thier Eid
but all islamic communities rejected them as musllim
thier leader was Alija Mohammad
they rejected the Muslim calender
and then they left this practice and become like us
they thought it is possible to fiz islamic practice in according with time
they were calling thier mosques as temple
but now all these finished and become muslis like other
Michael Jackson was that muslim
But now they dont do this
My concern is can you co-exist with other doctrines
like Jews who disobeyed Allah
Christians who gave him company
first you say can two god can be exist
and Dharmic religions who do not accept allah
No, two Gods cannot exist
only one God can exist
Then yes co-existing is possible
but problem is in practices
way of practice
and this can never be solved
Hindusim is the most irrational religion in world and the most dirty believes
because human does not have position in it
they worship the things that they make
they diverse society
All childlish practices
Veda is a good book
but who looks in it
Although it is not a Divine book
but some good Rishis have written
But according to us, Veda is the cognitive aspect of God
those who knew about Allah
there is a thesis
That is Veda is eternal knowledge
sum total of all knowledge
Crisis creates unity
when war was going in Afghanistan
Many christains socity funded Afghan Mujahidin against soviet
they belived this is a war against atheism
though it may be political tricks but
the reality is that in these three religion
Hinduism is not a divine or true religion
and can not be accepted
It should be totally rejected
Actually, Hinduism is not a proper term
but basically, we accept that only one religion exists
that is the relation of the soul with God
yeah like Islamic Sufism
I can quote Madhvacharya
1. Visnu is Supreme.
2. He is known by the study of the Vedas.
3. The Material world is real.
4. The jivas are different from the Lord.
5. The jivas are by nature subservient to the Lord.
6. In both the conditioned and liberated condition, the jivas are situated in higher and lower statuses.
7. Liberation is the attainment of Lord Visnu’s lotus-feet.
8. Pure devotion grants liberation.
9. Direct perception, logic and Vedic authority are the three sources of actual knowledge.
these are nine conclusions of vedas
visnu is the only god?
means tht Allah
Visnu means all pervading
that is the translation
not tht Vishnu?
That is the same
trimurti is just guna avataras
they are physically also there
or only adjectives or meanings
They are like many servants of the Supreme Absolute
who govern the diffrent worlds
we have calculated total 8 million 400 thousand species of life
created by god
this Shiava, Vishnu and Brahma are not that Ishawar?
something like that
but there are a few concepts which is not understandable to Islam
and transmigration of soul
actually, everything in this world is seen as part of the universal form of God
we say it Wahdatul Wajud
parts and not the whole
parts and not the whole
in islamic tasawuf
But God is a Supreme independent person
ok Sharma sir i m going to pray now
it must be time
Inshallah we will talk next time
im learning thngs so m happy
if the Lord desires
wish you pious Ramazan